Taking a Few Liberties

Bar eschews big sign and chicken wings

Saige Roberts

Dana DeToro, preparing a Brown Derby (below), says Liberty’s winter cocktails reflect flavors of the season such as cranberry, chestnut and warming bourbon.


The mood at Liberty Bar is part festive, part contemplative. Friends talk sports over craft beers at a roomy table. At the bar, a young professional works on her laptop, a briefcase at her feet and a cocktail at her elbow. Businessmen deep in conversation sip bourbon.

Bartender Dana DeToro holds court at a gleaming, copper-top bar. With the deftness of a magician, she measures, pours, adds dashes and splashes, shakes, conveys her creation to a glass, adds garnish, slides the libation forward and smiles.


“I think you’ll love this,” she says. “The grapefruit is fresh from Florida, and the honey is smoked wildflower honey from Full Moon Apiary (in Monticello) that we smoked here.” The bourbon is Florida Double Cask, distilled in St. Augustine, evidence of Liberty Bar’s preference for local and regional artisanal ingredients.

Garnished with a wedge of grapefruit, the concoction is a Brown Derby, one of the classic cocktails featured in Liberty Bar’s winter menu. Gone is the berry-infused summertime cocktail menu with its cucumber and watermelon juice. Winter offerings feature bourbon and flavors of the season: cranberry, chestnut, ginger, cinnamon, coconut, nutmeg and amaro, a bittersweet Italian liqueur.

Each season’s menu results from careful consideration.

“We have three meetings before we put the menus out,” DeToro said. “The bartenders get together and talk about the ingredients and flavors. They each have various interests (rum drinks, garnishes, Mexican flavors, Caribbean flavors) and they have returning customers who come in just for them.”

Liberty ingredients include syrups, tinctures and infusions made in-house. The food menu includes select dishes, modestly priced, for brunch, lunch and dinner. Burgers, yes. Wings, no. Grouper tacos and duck confit mac ’n’ cheese? Yes.

Attention to detail wins customers over.

DeToro’s sociology degree comes in handy, too. She puts it to good use with her customers and the Liberty Bar team and, of late, in establishing a Tallahassee chapter of the U.S. Bartenders Guild whose meetings give bartenders opportunities to learn about brands and trends and to brainstorm together. A transplant from Fort Lauderdale, DeToro and her colleague Richard deMontmollin applaud Tallahassee’s culture of collaboration. 

“At first, we didn’t know if we’d be supported, really,” deMontmollin said. “People thought we were crazy — no chicken wings, no Bud Light, no giant sign …”

Four years later, with a partner restaurant The Hawthorn newly open next door, they like the way the ingredients are coming together.

“It lets us think bigger and put our hearts into it, express ourselves,” DeToro said.

Cheers to that. 

Classic Brown Derby

  • 1.5 oz. Florida Double Cask bourbon
  • 1 oz. fresh Florida grapefruit juice
  • Half-ounce of smoked honey syrup (half honey, half water)

Shake ingredients with ice to chill. Strain into a chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with a dehydrated wedge or fresh twist of grapefruit.


Liberty Bar & Restaurant

1307 N. Monroe Street, in Midtown; LibertyTLH.com, 284-7966; open daily 5 p.m. – 2 a.m.; 11 a.m.–2 p.m., 5 p.m.–2 a.m. on weekends

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Send me information about...
  •  Tallahassee Magazine
  •  Emerald Coast Magazine
  •  850 Business Magazine
  •  Northwest Florida Weddings


Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Featured Articles



Homecoming pageantry is only the beginning for the university’s royal courts.
Tom  Flanigan

Tom Flanigan

Revered for his local reporting, Flanigan mainly wants citizens to listen to each other.
TMH Golden Gala

TMH Golden Gala

Months of planning lead up to Tallahassee Memorial HealthCare’s signature fundraising event of the year.
Homemade Holidays

Homemade Holidays

Create warm memories with old-fashioned, homemade decorations and goodies. DIY guru Kim Thacker shows us how.
Edit ModuleShow Tags